It's very important to follow these basic tips:
- Be direct and concise about what the employee did and when they did it.
- Document verbal discussions and warnings you had with the employee.
- Document the discussed expectations and follow up plans for correction.
- Remove emotion, sarcasm, the use of "you" and keep a neutral tone in written and verbal form.
- Focus on facts and do not exaggerate the situation with unnecessary details.
"Amy just isn't pulling her weight which is causing co-workers to take on extra work."
- Instead: Amy has failed to produce and send ABC reports each Thursday to the accounting department for the last 3 weeks. Because these reports have not been sent, the accounting department must redo their XYZ reports to add missing data never sent by Amy.
"You show no desire to be at work on time and you always have poor excuses."
- Instead: I'm concerned about your attendance. The last two months you've had 6 late arrivals on ABCDEF days and called in without notice twice on XY days without an acceptable excuse or doctor note.
"Yet again, Amy is making mistake after mistake which shows she just doesn't care to do a good job."
- Instead: Amy has made another mistake on her customer order sheet. This will be her 3rd time to submit a non-complete order sheet. Amy received training on how to properly complete the order sheet on X date and was directed to ask questions if she was unsure on anything.
"You're out again? Can you not work a full week. This is ridiculous."
- Instead: Amy, we hired you to work a full time M-F 40 hour a week position that you accepted. Your repeated absences are interfering with your work schedule as you've only worked one 40 hour week over the last 5 weeks. I need to know how we can ensure that you meet the 40 hour expectation as that's necessary and required of this position.
Under no circumstance should you ever make comments about another employees performance in a public area because people are always ease dropping! Don't create a mess and unnecessary office gossip. Remember that employee performance should always be kept confidential.